This is not a review. Just a few spoiler-ridden thoughts on the movie, which I need to get out of my system.
People all over the world today, including those in urban
India, lead increasingly homogenised lives. We watch the same American
television programming, use the same kind of brands, and eat the same kind of
food. It’s not just about a job anymore,
any job that would support a family back home. Our aspirations for a career revolve
around the more first-worldly ideal of finding one’s true calling. Likewise,
our movies have come to reflect this (or a more exaggerated version of this)
reality. Take the toast-making, skydiving trio of Zindagi Milegi Na Dobara. I can’t
help but feel that they would fit in rather more comfortably in New York than
Mumbai. Transplant the leads of Dil Chahta Hai to London, and it would make absolutely
no difference to the narrative. Which is probably why films like Cocktail and
Ekk Main aur Ekk Tu completely dispense with an Indian backdrop. And which is
why Kai Po Che is the most refreshing film I have seen in a long time.
Kai Po Che is an Indian
film in every sense of the word. Yes, of course there is song-and-dance, and
Manja manages to evoke an atmosphere that reams of dialogue could possibly
never establish. But more importantly it’s the world Govind, Omi and Ishan
inhabit that makes the film resonate so much. You can see the dust, the sweat. Here, an eleven year old’s most
pressing concern is the goti championship in his neighbourhood. A young man
longingly fingers the plastic covered seats of a new car. Dates are carried out
in extreme secrecy. Travelling inside a Roadways bus is more uncomfortable than
on the roof. Sure, finding love is important, but achieving other goals
(monetary, political or, otherwise) more urgent. This is a movie where you cheer the Indian
Cricket team on for a match you know they
have won. Because you know cricket can resolve feuds between friends. That
it can magically paper over religious fissures. You pray the ending doesn’t
enter the territory, you know it’s heading for, when a dazed Omi finds his Mama
injured by Ali’s dad. And when the fatal shot hits, you hold back tears, wishing
that Ishan and Govind could sort it all out, Omi and Ishan could sort it
all out.
If only Bolly-wood can now come up with an ode to female
friendship. One that preferably does not involve two pretty girls falling for the
same guy.
Ok here's mine: What I felt after the last scene was that this is the most sensible representation of India that Bollywood has conjured up in the past 3-4 years, given the trend is to make utterly stupid 100 crore grossing films set in semi-urban/ rural India where a shirt-remover cop does monkey steps(and watching him you don't know whether to laugh or cry or lament) or the glossy ones that you've talked about above. It had all the right ingredients of cricket, friendship, religion pitched in. Everything is so real that your tears flow on uninhibited. Spoiler alert/Side Note: Ishaan HAD to die in the end because he was so pampered and self-obsessed that we wouldn't have fallen in love with him otherwise.
ReplyDeleteAnd as for female friendship, we are in dire need of some cool female writers who can tell the world what a treasure it is. :)
By what I wrote, I didn't mean to say that Dabbang or Singham were bad films (I don't think they were). And Dil Chahta Hai is an all time favourite :)
DeleteAlso Zoya Akhtar is female, and she made ZNMD. Good enough credentials, don't you think?
And ooh I was in love with Ishaan, right after the earthquake relief camp scene. Didn't need him to die at all.
DeleteIt was so hard for me to digest that Ishaan had died, that I had to come up with some plausible excuse for the director/script-writer to kill him ..mostly to console myself. :)
DeleteYes women are ambivalent...men are not. ;)
yes Ishaan didn't need to die to fall in love with...
Deletehe just related to the reality so perfectly that he was a star even before you realised that :)
agreed! a truly indian film through and through. Theres something about these whole "not in india but for indians" films that somehow somewhere limit how much one can relate to them.
ReplyDeleteand NO! Ishan should not have died! :( a near fatal injury that he would recover from would do just as well, although it would probably not make for as much as a poignant ending..but it was too sad.